Strategy. He’s all about strategy. From stats to demographics to ROI and R&D, he’s thought through everything.

He’s methodical and organized and asks questions revolving leveraging the assets we have to strengthen our future as an organization. Yes, Mr. X is a consultant I meet with regularly to discuss our visual communication at The A21 Campaign. After the logistics and implementation has been discussed, I conclude our meeting with the most important question in my mind: So, are you dating anyone yet?

He’s a great guy. Smart, talented, loves Jesus and has a full set of teeth (don’t roll your eyes, teeth are important!). And of course my MatchMakingMeter goes off the richter scale  when I meet an eligible men who is single. I incessantly hear women say, Where have all the cowboys gone? [sung like Paula Cole circa 1995] and act like good men are as imaginative as TuPac Shakur.

He smiles sheepishly because we’ve discussed this before. Dating, women, church, the whole nine. But this time he opens up to reveal his new strategy. New strategy, I asked with piqued interest. Oh wow, I’m so excited to hear about it! He said,

My new strategy is just to meet someone at the market or coffee shop and hope she’s a Christian.

Oh Internet, you should’ve seen my face! A mixture of shock, horror, and disbelief caused my jaw to drop. The man who brilliantly analyzes and plans and forecasts is hoping he’ll stumble into a gorgeous woman who hopefully loves Jesus. And then I died. Twice.

But here’s the reality: he’s not the only one who thinks this. I don’t want to categorize all men because its 2013 and stereotypes are so 1985, but this is the mindset for many evangelical males.

Do you blame them?

In the past week I’ve connected with four men who are single, eligible, and regularly attend church. For clarity sake [and anonymity] I will refer to them as Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.

  • Matthew [38] is an educated, white-collar, divorcee with no kids who serves in ministry at his Pentecostal church.
  • Mark [29] is a fun but conservative Christian who wants to be married, but is fearful of dating anyone at church.
  • Luke [30] has attempted dating within his non-denominational church, but feels doing so has now marred him from dating again for fear of a scarlet letter.
  •  John [24] is hilarious and says he wants to get married, but based on his own admission, his Baptist friends advocate for predestination and believe she will appear in his path. [Oh Lawd help me.]
Without going into too much detail, there was a current theme running through our conversations as to why men may be shy in pulling the trigger and asking ladies out. For starters, each claimed they wanted to be married and believed most men [specifically within the Church] want to be in relationship with someone. But the question is left to be answered—then why not date within church?

Here are some reasons:

  1. Reputations. Luke said it’s a no-win situation. He has been attending his church for five years and roughly pursued four girls [a few coffee dates, maybe a couple dinners]. All of a sudden he’s now that guy who preys on [not prays for] women. In the world’s eyes he’s a lazy dater, but at church he’s a player.
  2. Eliminations. Dating in church is like playing “Let’s Make A Deal,” said John. You can strike up a deal and accept it, but you’ve eliminated doors two and three. Apparently, if a guy goes out with one girl at church, it has eliminated him from ever dating her friends. [Oh my word, this is SO true! Its the carnal rule in caddy friendships: don’t date my ex.]
  3. Complications. Dating complicates things for men. Mark was engaged to a woman from his church, but they realized it wasn’t the best fit. Instead of the coming around and supporting their decision, their friends became her friends and left him to deal with disappointment alone. Matthew also said that serving in ministry puts you in a fishbowl: all eyes are watching. His concern is dating someone and discovering they aren’t The One will cause people to think his discernment and judgement is off.
  4. Pressure. Every men I spoke with stated this invisible layer of pressure they feel regarding dating women within their church. John joked, It’s like they become all P31* on me and try acting super holy. I just want a normal girl. Most men admitted to sensing when a girl was into them and felt pressure to either run away and not lead her on or awkwardly try to handle that relationship.
    An interesting item to note is that though each man admitted to failing in pursuing women they were interested in, every one said they would want to do the pursuing. I’m not an archaic meat-head—joked John—but there is something thrilling about chasing a girl and having her reciprocate the feelings. If she’s too forward, it comes off as desperate. FYI ladies, we can all hear your biological clock. 
Mr. X—a strategic consultant and personal friend—definitely heard my take on his new so-called strategy. But more than anything, I was grateful for his candid honesty. Dre Kelly who commented on the previous post, timidly admitted that he struggles in finding the right match and not being judged by women. Wow. I totally understood what he was talking about [FYI I went to high school with Dre and he’s great! And single! And loves Jesus! Hook it up…]. More than anything, I was sensitively awakened to the idea that perhaps, women are a bit hard on men. 
Sure, do I think men should step up, buck up, and ask a girl out? Absolutely. But after having extensive conversations what amazing guys throughout the years, I really felt the need to show a different side.
Most men possess a sense of strength and confidence in what they feel gifted in. But rarely is a man confident in the reciprocity of love. Instead of judging men for the inability to step-up-to-the-plate, perhaps we can dialogue about what women can do to make this process a win for both parties.
Love, love, love,
B
PS: For those who commented on yesterday’s post, I really appreciate the feedback. Dialogue is healthy and allows for us to hear perspectives of those walking out their faith in the realm of dating.
*P31 is referring to the Proverbs 31 woman who is darn near perfect. In my head, she is like Beth Moore. But don’t tell her I told you.

Pin It on Pinterest